Hedgerow Harvest

Sustain, Retain, Maintain

The Dangers of Raw Mushrooms

We got a comment for the post on Gluten-free Pasta.  Robbie mentioned raw food.  The raw food movement makes a lot of sense, because, duh, you are eating the whole food, nothing processed.  It’s a great idea.  Just not for mushrooms.  Here’s why.

As you can tell from the site, I’m a bit of a mushroom nut (heavy on the nut).  Mushrooms are fabulously versatile, from medicines, to dyes and inks, and yes, even paper.  O, and food.  As a food source though, mushrooms have one big problem:  monomethylhydrazine.  MMH is most commonly found in rocket fuel.  Many cases of “mushroom poisoning” can be attributed to this chemical.  That’s the bad news, here’s the good:  MMH is a volatile organic compound, so cooking drives it away.

Pay close attention to that word:  Cooking.  Never, ever eat raw mushrooms!  Any mushroom.  That includes those white button mushrooms you buy at the grocery store or get on your salads in a restaurant.

There are two types of exposure:  Acute and Chronic.  ‘Acute’ isn’t talking about the cuteness of the exposure.  It means ‘once’.  ‘Chronic’ means ‘daily’.

Low level acute exposure to MMH results in nausea, stomach cramps, and diarrhea, while severe poisoning can result in convulsions, jaundice, coma, or death.

Clinical testing of chronic exposure to 2 and 5 ppm MMH in rats have shown a mortality rate of 2-2.5%.  Other symptoms include lethargy, loss of fur, and slower growth rates in young animals.  In other animal tests, dogs developed photophobia due to changes in the nictitating membranes of the eyes; dogs, rats, and monkeys showed dramatic decreases in hematocrit values, splenic hemosiderosis (enlargement of the spleen due to iron overload caused by accumulation of hemosiderin), and other nastiness.

In humans, MMH acts on the central nervous system and interferes with the normal use and function of pyridoxal phosphate, better known as Vitamin B6.  This vitamin is absolutely necessary for the body to release glucose from glycogen.  Glucose is the sugar on which your body runs.  You know how you feel when you have a sugar crash?  No glucose and your body runs out of fuel.  <thud>

MMH has also been shown to be carcinogenic in small mammals.

The mushroom that has the highest concentration of MMH is the False Morel (Gyromitra esculenta).  This mushroom is only edible if it has been cooked thoroughly, and then, by all accounts, it is quite tasty.  I heard a sad tale in one of my mushroom club meetings.  An old man in Europe loved False Morels.  He would get his wife to cook them.  He would sit outside while she worked over a hot stove in their cottage.  He had a nice meal, while his wife keeled over dead.  The process of cooking caused the MMH to evaporate, where wifey breathed it in.

Here is a picture of the False Morel.  I didn’t take this picture.  I’ve never actually found a False Morel!

Gyromitra esculenta

I did take this picture, though, of the first morel I found in Spring 2012:

See the similarity?

The point of scaring you?  Don’t eat mushrooms raw!  Cook them first.  Our favorite way is with butter, garlic, and white wine.  Since MMH is a volatile organic compound, heating or drying drives it off.  Meaning that edible mushrooms are absolutely safe if they have been dried or cooked.

The next time you are served raw mushrooms on a salad, send it back to the kitchen and ask for sautéed instead!

Please, Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: